eleticle

Core No. 02Logged 14 Oct 2026

Can truck productivity improve while every haul route gets worse?

Worked example · constructed numbers · no site data

A worked example with made-up hours and haul rates: one truck fleet on a short route and a long one. We compare tonnes per truck-hour before and after a dispatch change, route by route and for the whole fleet.

What we found

  • The report says betterFleet productivity rose 15.7 %, from 210 to 243 t per truck-hour, while each haul route moved 10 % fewer tonnes per truck-hour.
  • The hours movedAfter the change, the short haul took 80 % of the truck-hours, up from 40 %. The fleet rate is an average weighted by those hours.
  • Same share of short hauls, lowerKeep the short haul at its earlier 40 % of the hours and the after month makes 189 t per truck-hour: 10 % down, like each route.
  • What the mix addedAt the after month's route rates, moving hours to the short haul lifts the fleet rate from 189 to 243 t per truck-hour.
  1. Method
  2. 01The report
  3. 02The mix
  4. 03Like with like
  5. 04Before crediting

Method

Four made-up rows, one weighted average

  • ConstructedTen truck-hours a monthOf ten truck-hours, 4 short haul at 300 and 6 long haul at 150 t per truck-hour before; 8 at 270 and 2 at 135 after. Not from any site.
  • EstablishedAverages on fixed weightsA fleet rate is a weighted average; comparing periods on fixed weights is direct standardisation. A total that moves against all its parts is called Simpson's paradox.
  • CheckedExact arithmeticThe four rows give every value, by hand or in a spreadsheet. Our short script recomputes each one and checks the page shows it; the figures and the slider use the same numbers.

The references are under Sources, at the end of the page.

01 · The report

Productivity is up. Both routes are down.

One fleet hauls from a pit on two routes, a short haul and a long haul. After a dispatch change, the monthly report shows 243 t per truck-hour, up from 210. Split the same months by route, and both routes move 10 % fewer tonnes per truck-hour.

t per truck-hour · by route and fleetRoutes −10 % · fleet +15.7 %
Before and after, by route. Short haul 300 to 270 t per truck-hour, 10 % lower, on 40 % then 80 % of the truck-hours. Long haul 150 to 135, 10 % lower, on 60 % then 20 %. Fleet 210 to 243, 15.7 % higher.

Circle area and the percentages show each route's share of the month's truck-hours; the diamonds are the fleet. Every number is constructed for the example.

The arithmetic is right. The fleet rate is total tonnes over total truck-hours, and in the after month 80 % of those hours were on the short haul, up from 40 %.

02 · The mix

A fleet rate is an average weighted by hours

The fleet rate sits between the two route rates, wherever the hours put it. Move hours to the short haul and it rises, whatever the trucks did on each route. Slide the after month's mix and watch the report.

Fleet t per truck-hour · after month80 % short haul · 243 t/h · +15.7 % on the report
Fleet t per truck-hour against the share of truck-hours on the short haul. At the before month's route rates the line runs from 150 to 300; at the after month's rates from 135 to 270, always 10 % lower. Before, at 40 % short haul: 210. After, at 80 %: 243. After, at 40 %: 189. Past 55.6 % short haul, the after month reports more than 210.

Each line is one month's route rates applied to any mix of hours. The after line is 10 % below the before line everywhere.

At 80 % of truck-hours on the short haul, the after month reports 243 t per truck-hour, 15.7 % above the before month, although each route's rate is 10 % lower. Above 55.6 % on the short haul, the report shows a gain.

It runs the other way too

Send more hours to the long haul, as a pit deepens or a far dump opens, and the fleet rate can fall even when every route improves.

More tonnes, but which?

With the same truck-hours, the after month moved 15.7 % more tonnes. Whether that helps depends on what the mine plan needed moved. Rose and co-authors (2026) list shortening waste hauls, at the cost of later production, as one way to lift short-term productivity.

03 · Like with like

Hold the mix, then compare

Put the after month's route rates on the before month's hours: 189 t per truck-hour, 10 % below 210, the same as each route. The 33 t per truck-hour on the report then splits into two parts.

The +33 on the report, in two partsRoutes −21 · mix +54
Before, 210 t per truck-hour. Routes 10 % lower at the before mix: minus 21, to 189. More hours on the short haul: plus 54, to the reported 243.

Routes: the after month's rates on the before month's hours, 189 against 210. Mix: the after month's own hours against the before month's, at the after month's rates, 243 against 189.

Which month's hours you hold changes the split, not the verdict here: on the after month's hours, the before month would make 270, and 243 is again 10 % lower. When route rates change by different percentages, the answer can depend on the mix you hold, so say which one you used.

04 · Before crediting the change

Six checks on a reported productivity gain

A fleet rate that rose is a question, not an answer. Work through these in order before crediting the change.

  1. Which hour is the denominator?The same kind of truck-hour in both months, named from GMG's time categories.
  2. Which routes are comparable?Same loading unit, dump, distance and lift; tonne-kilometres per operating hour on equivalent flat haul distance bridge the rest.
  3. Compare within each route.Each route's rate before and after, with its hours.
  4. Aggregate on a stated mix.Usually the earlier month's hours, shown beside the reported figure.
  5. Report the mix as its own number.Each route's share of truck-hours, both months. A new mix may be what the change was for.
  6. What else changed?Payload, road condition, gradient, weather, delays and queueing at the loader.

A fixed route mix shows whether the trucks did better on comparable work, not why. A model trained on fleet totals has the same blind spot: give it the route.

Sources

  1. Global Mining Guidelines Group (2020). A standardized time classification framework for mobile equipment in surface mining: operational definitions, time usage model, and key performance indicators. Version of 13 July 2020, published 31 August 2020. GMG.
  2. Simpson, E. H. (1951). The interpretation of interaction in contingency tables. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B, 13(2), 238–241. doi:10.1111/j.2517-6161.1951.tb00088.x.
  3. Ahmad, O. B., Boschi-Pinto, C., Lopez, A. D., Murray, C. J. L., Lozano, R. and Inoue, M. (2001). Age standardization of rates: a new WHO standard. World Health Organization, GPE paper No. 31. PDF, for direct standardisation.
  4. Rose, D., Topal, E., Barakos, G. and Akdag, S. (2026). Toward an overall system effectiveness metric for truck–shovel systems in surface mines. Mining, Metallurgy & Exploration, online first. doi:10.1007/s42461-026-01748-0, for equivalent flat haul distance and tonne-kilometres per operating hour.