The stope volume matches the design. Can dilution and ore loss still be high?
Worked example · constructed stope · no survey data
A worked example with one made-up longhole stope. We move its excavation 1 m sideways from the design, into the hanging wall, and follow what the survey volume, the ore left behind and the mill would show.
What we found
- Volume on plan, ore left behindThe surveyed void matched the planned 10,000 m³, while 10 % of the planned ore stayed in the footwall.
- Two errors cancelThe excavation took 1,000 m³ of waste outside the design and left 1,000 m³ of planned ore behind. They net to zero, so the volume check sees neither.
- Tonnes on plan, metal shortWith one ore grade, barren waste, equal densities and everything mined sent to the mill, it gets the planned tonnes at 90 % of the planned grade.
- Few track underbreak by surfaceOf 19 mines in a study published in 2020, 14 measured underbreak, rock inside the planned excavation left unmined, but only two compiled it systematically by stope surface.
Method
One constructed stope, its walls moved
- ConstructedA 10,000 m³ stope10 m wide, 25 m down dip and 40 m along strike, dipping 70°. The surveyed void is the design moved 1 m into the hanging wall. Not from any site.
- AssumedWhat reaches the millEqual densities, one ore grade, barren waste, and everything mined sent to the mill.
- EstablishedPlain geometryVoid minus design equals overbreak minus underbreak. The terms are used as the sources define them.
- CheckedExact arithmeticThe stope's dimensions give every value, by hand or in a spreadsheet. Our short script recomputes them and looks for each key statement on the page.
The references are under Sources, at the end of the page.
01 · The survey
The volume matches. What does that show?
A longhole stope is designed to take 10,000 m³ of ore. After firing and mucking, a survey of the void reports 10,000 m³. On volume, the stope reconciles exactly.
Hypothetical reconciliation · m³
The excavation reaches 1,000 m³ past the hanging-wall design, while 1,000 m³ of planned ore stays in the footwall.
The difference is zero because the two errors cancel. A stope mined exactly to its design would read zero too.
02 · Move the walls
A net volume hides both walls
The section cuts across the stope: 10 m wide, 25 m down dip and 40 m along strike, dipping 70°. Each metre a wall moves is 1,000 m³. Move the two walls and watch the void.
Design outline dashed, surveyed void solid; where they meet, the edge shows solid. Depths are square to the wall; on the hanging wall that depth is the equivalent linear overbreak/slough, ELOS.
With 1.0 m on each wall, the void is 10,000 m³, the plan exactly. Yet 1,000 m³ of ore stayed in the footwall and 1,000 m³ of waste came out in its place: 90.0 % of the planned ore extracted, dilution 10.0 % of the excavated volume.
Overbreak alone shows
Mine 1 m past the hanging wall and leave the footwall clean, and the void is 11,000 m³: the net catches it. Leave 1 m of footwall ore as well, and it vanishes.
Two ways to state dilution
Here 1,000 m³ of waste in the 10,000 m³ mined is 10 %. Against the 9,000 m³ of ore mined, it is 11.1 %. McCarthy (2001) gives both, so say which. The slider uses the first.
03 · At the mill
Tonnes on plan, metal short
Give waste and ore the same density and the ore one grade throughout, and send everything mined to the mill. It receives the planned tonnes, but only 90 % of the planned metal.
Assumed: equal densities, one ore grade, barren waste, and all of the excavated material, and nothing else, reaching the mill.
Outside the design is not always barren
“Outside” says where, not what. Potvin and co-authors report a mine whose wall rock carried disseminated grade, softening the cost of overbreak. Waste can also be lighter or heavier than ore. Neither changes the three volumes.
The void is not the delivery
A survey measures the hole. Broken ore left in the stope, fill falling in, and loads mixed with other stopes change what reaches the mill.
04 · What to report
Three volumes, then the net
Report what the survey can tell apart, surface by surface, as face-level reconciliation does. The net goes last, as a cross-check.
- Planned ore extracted.The design's ore that was mined, as volume and share of plan.
- Excavated outside the design.By surface: hanging wall, footwall, sidewalls, crown and floor, as volume and as ELOS.
- Planned ore left behind.By surface, after checking it is rock in place, not muck or a scan shadow.
- The net difference, last.A cross-check, never the verdict.
- Tonnes and grade from what was delivered.From the muck and the mill, not from the survey.
Once its coverage and alignment are checked, a survey set against its design gives all three volumes. A model that does it surface by surface for every stope keeps them from being netted away.
Sources
- Potvin, Y., Woodward, K. R., McFadyen, B., Thin, I. and Grant, D. (2020). Benchmarking of stope design and reconciliation practices. In J. Wesseloo (ed.), UMT 2020: Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Underground Mining Technology, Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth, 299–308. doi:10.36487/ACG_repo/2035_14.
- McFadyen, B., Woodward, K. R., Potvin, Y. and Grenon, M. (2020). A new stope reconciliation approach. In J. Wesseloo (ed.), UMT 2020, Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth, 335–350. doi:10.36487/ACG_repo/2035_17.
- McFadyen, B., Grenon, M., Woodward, K. and Potvin, Y. (2023). Predicting open stope performance at an octree resolution using multivariate models. Journal of the Southern African Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, 123(6), 309–320. doi:10.17159/2411-9717/2770/2023, for what a cavity survey measures and what hides a surface from it.
- McCarthy, P. L. (2001). Mining dilution and losses in underground mining. In A. C. Edwards (ed.), Mineral Resource and Ore Reserve Estimation, AusIMM Monograph 23, Melbourne, 333–336.
- Capes, G. and Milne, D. (2008). A compilation of dilution graph data for open stope hangingwall design. In SHIRMS 2008: Proceedings of the First Southern Hemisphere International Rock Mechanics Symposium, Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth, 149–162. doi:10.36487/ACG_repo/808_19, for ELOS, after Clark and Pakalnis (1997).